This article is aimed at a comparative analysis of LNG and MDF as a marine fuel in terms of their impact on the environment. A bulk carrier with a deadweight of 50000 is given as the object of study. The cycle of each type of fuel was distributed in three stages: Well-to-Tank (WtT), Tank-to-Wake (TtW) and Well-to-Wake(WtW). In process modeling, the effect of each stage was analyzed based on 5 environmental impact categories. Global Warming Potential (GWP), Acidification Potential (AP), Photochemical Potential (POCP), Eutrophication Potential (EP) and Particulate Matter (PM). The results of the analysis showed that the emission levels for LNG were significantly lower than for MDO in all categories. For example, option 1 was the best with the lowest emission levels per 1.0 * 107 MJ of fuel consumption: 977 tons CO2eq (for GWP), 1.76 tons S02eq (for AP), 1.18 tons Neq (for EP), 4.28 tons NMVOC equivalent (for POCP) and 26 kg PM 2.5 equivalent (PM). The conclusion of this scientific article is the deduction about the advantages of LNG in terms of environmental impact over MDO.
LNG, MDO, marine oil, ships operating with LNG, IMO, Emissions
1. Sangsoo Etwang, Byongug Jeong ,Kwanghyo Jung, Mingyu Kim and Peilin Zhou. Life Cycle Asses-ment of LNG Fueled Vessel in Domestic Services j.Mar.Sci.Eng 2019,7,359
2. Tan, R.B.;Wijaya, D.;Khoo, H.H. LCI(Life cycle in ventory) analysis of fuels and electricity generation in Singapore. Energy 2010,35 4910-4916
3. Tagliaferri,C.,Clift,R.,Lettieri,P.,Chapman,C. Liq uefied natural gas for the UK: A life cycle assessment.Int. J.Life Cycle Assess 2017,49,1944-1956
4. Bengtsson, S., Andersson,K,; Fridell, E. Life cycle Assesment of Marine Fuels: A Comparative Study of Four Fossil Fuels for Marine Propulsion; Chalmers University of Technology: Gothenburg, Sweden,2011
5. Jeong,B.Comparative Analysis of SOx Emission- Compliant Options for Marine Vessels from Environmental Perspective. J.Korean Soc. Power Syst. Eng. 2018, 22,72-78
6. Jeong,B,;Jang,H,;Zhou,P,;Lee,J.U. Investigation on marine LNG propulsion systems for LNG carriers through an enhanced hybrid decision making model. J.Clean.Prod.2019,230,98-115
7. Rocco,M.V. :Lange,S.,Pigoli,L.,Colombo,E.,Pellegrini, L.A. Assessing the energy intensity of alternative chemical and cryogenic natural gas purification processes in LNG production. J.Clean.Prod. 2019, 208, 827-840
8. 8. Internet istochnik https://www.imo.Org/en/OurWork/Environment/P ages/Fourth-IMO-Greenhouse-Gas-Study-2020. aspx
9. Turkin, V. A. Ocenka riskov ekspluatacii su dovyh tehnicheskih sredstv s uchetom vozmozhnosti vozniknoveniya kiberincidentov / V. A. Turkin, D. A. Davydov, A. A. Styazhkin // Morskie intellektual'nye tehnologii. - 2021. -T. 4. - № 2(53). - S. 58-66. - DOIhttps://doi.org/10.37220/MIT.2021.52.2.070.
10. Sistema instrumental'nogo monitoringa koncentracii vrednyh veschestv v otrabotavshih gazah sudovyh dizeley / E. V. Ignatenko, V. A. Turkin, A. V. Scherbina, L. N. Pisarenko // Lazerno-informacionnye tehnologii v medicine, biologii, geoekologii i na transporte -2020: trudy XXVIII Mezhdunarodnoy konferencii, Novorossiysk, 07-12 sentyabrya 2020 goda. - Novorossiysk: Penzenskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet, 2020. - S. 233-235.
11. Modina, M. A., Shkoda V. V., Kashin Ya. M. Efficiency of methods for cleaning combustion products from sulfur oxides // Bulatov Readings. - 2019.-V. 5.-S. 42-44.
12. Plahotnyuk A. N., Kreminsky V. O., Shkoda V. V., Kazaev A. A. Input filter capacitance of the converter feeding the inductor of a two-dimensional electric machine // Energy and resource-saving technologies and installations VRNA-20: Materials 6th All-Russian Scientific Conference, Krasnodar, November 19-21,2020. - Krasnodar: Federal State State Military Educational Institution of Eligher Education “Krasnodar Eligher Military Aviation School for Pilots named after Elero of the Soviet Union A.K. Serov" of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, 2020. - P. 38-42.
13. Kashin Ya. M., Belov A. A., Shkoda V. V. [et al.] Generalized algorithm for selecting power supply installations for telecommunications facilities // Bulletin of the Adygei State University. Series 4: Natural-mathematical and technical sciences. -2020. - No. 1 (256). - S. 54-61.
14. Elekert E. V., Vladetskaya E. A., Bratan S. M., Kharchenko A. O. Influence of external factors on the technological system of a high-precision machine tool in conditions of floating workshops // Marine Intelligent Technologies. - 2021. - T. 4. -No. 2 (53). - S. 33-37. - DOIhttps://doi.org/10.37220/MIT.2021.52.2.066.
15. Boran-Keshishyan A. L., Zamorenov M. V., Florya P. N. [et al.] Functioning of a technical system with an instantly replenished time reserve, taking into account prevention // Marine Intelligent Technologies. - 2021. - V. 1. - No. 4 (54). - S. 258-264. - DOIhttps://doi.org/10.37220/MIT.2021.54.4.061
